The Head and the Heart, Vic Theater, Chicago, March 7, 2012
It occurred to me recently that the concert “encore” is sort of like the adult version of reviving Tinkerbell.
If you believe in fairies, clap your hands! If you are getting legitimately concerned that your favorite song off the entire album hasn’t been played yet and we seem to be leaving the stage with our instruments forever, CLAP YOUR HANDS.
We all know how it’s going to work out, but we play along because it seems way too risky not to. Is Billy Joel really not going to play “Piano Man?” Of course he is; that’s why you came, and he knows that. But he’s going to make you beg for it.
As a child, watching a PBS broadcast of the Mary Martin staging of Peter Pan on low-fi 1980s VHS, I was always tempted to see what might happen if just-this-once I didn’t clap my hands. Would Tink be gone forever? (Sidenote: She was, let’s be real, juuuust the tiniest bit obnoxious. Even my four-year-old self didn’t really suffer minxes gladly.) I was ultra-intrigued, but the potential crushing guilt of being the child who had changed the course of fictional humanity forever was too strong for me, and at the last minute I always burst into full-wingspan applause to bring our girl back to never-Neverland.
No such personal debate was necessary when, last week, The Head and the Heart played at the The Vic. If kids clapped dutifully to prevent the publicly televised demise of a fairy, this audience applauded desperately for TH&TH–and the reward of hearing the folky, aching, hurtling “Down In the Valley”–after all hope of another tune seemed lost– was far better than anything Tink ever drummed up.
I am on my way/ I am on my way/I am on my way back to where I started…